The Unnatural Welfare Given To Elites

penston(55)
Published in
#mmt
Words
718
Reading
4 min
Listen
Play
9y

When I was about 5 or 6 years old, my mother told me, with a sigh, that the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. When I asked her to explain to me how that worked, she couldn't. All that mattered was that we were poor, Ireland was in a recession and the future looked even less rosy than the terrible reception on our black and white TV.

If you have a 5 or 6 year old, go and grab them right now because I'm about to explain one of the ways rich people get richer.

Welfare

We all know that most unemployed people receive welfare. I say most, instead of all, because I've been unemployed a few times and only received welfare once (the first time) and I can at least confirm that there are people who don't qualify for welfare because of their immigration status, personal wealth or, you know, reasons. Because!

However, there are forms of welfare that are given by the central bank to those who have spare money lying around. For what reason? Because they have spare money lying around. That's how the World works!

Okay, I realise that I may already have lost the 5 and 6 year olds in the audience, but I hope that the grown ups can hang in there a little longer.

W4E

Welfare for Elites (I've made up the term and the acronym, W4E - please spread it around like teenage wildfire) comes from two directions at the central bank.

The first W4E is the interest that is paid on the balances in reserve accounts. They're like deposit accounts that commercial banks have at the central bank. Not every central bank pays this kind of interest, but those who do are literally giving money away for no good reason. The more money banks have in their accounts, the more welfare they receive. They don't have to do anything to earn it. Do you have a deposit account that pays interest?

Why do central banks pay this interest? It's not like they're incentivising the commercial banks to remain as customers because... it's the central bank - they have no other option but to keep their money in those reserve accounts. The only reason for having this is to enable the rich to get richer.

What about the second form of W4E that's paid out by the central bank? Well, this one is a particular pet hate of mine - bonds.

For reasons that haven't existed for decades, governments believe that they need to borrow money so that they can pay for things. They 'borrow' money by selling securities (we'll just call them bonds here, though) to a select group of banks who can then sell them on to anyone who wants them. And you'd better believe that people want them!

Why wouldn't they? Bonds are 100% risk free and you get free money just for having them! Fat cats who have spare money lying around love to buy bonds and receive the welfare that comes with them. They get a warm, fuzzy feeling because money comes so easily to them, like kisses from Mommy. Oh, they feel so loved!

Poor people don't get to share the love because they don't have spare money lying around. So, the gap between rich and poor widens. Inequality growth marches on. And thanks to inflation, low wage growth, increasing rents (yes, yes, that's part of inflation, but it's frightfully important!), etc., the poor really do get poorer.

Is This The Natural Order?

Central banks don't need to pay interest on deposit accounts or savings accounts. In fact, the central bank deliberately manipulates the money market to keep the interest rate above zero. So, without their interference, no one would have any reason to buy bonds (just as the government has no good reason to sell them) and your mortgage (or your landlord's mortgage) payments would be lower.

If the natural interest rate is zero, then what we have now is unnatural and we must burn it! Burn it with fire! Take a step towards halting inequality growth by taking away part of the Welfare for Elites. Some scaredy cats are so afraid it'll result in a weaker currency that they've filled their kitty litter, but all you're doing is removing distortion.
The Unnatural Welfare Given To Elites | Ecency