RE: RE: REJECTED: Formal Proposal for Rules Governing Downvoting within the “Proof of Brain” Tribe
You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: REJECTED: Formal Proposal for Rules Governing Downvoting within the “Proof of Brain” Tribe

Words
497
Reading
3 min
Listen
Play
5y

I am tagging the top 150 or so accounts on the POB richlist who have not yet voted "YES" or "NO" on either of the following two proposals to the POB community:

The first proposal expires within the next 12 hours or so. The second proposal expires in a couple days.

For a proposal to be ratified, it needs greater than 50% of the staked-POB to vote "YES". As such, not voting (i.e. abstaining) is effectively a "NO" vote.

Both proposals are aimed at eliminating the ability of 'whales' on the POB platform to use downvotes as a weapon against people or ideas they disagree with. There might be a better way, but these two proposals are a first attempt.

Before voting, you should check out this post by scooter77@scooter77 explaining some of the pitfalls of the proposed rules and why he voted "NO".

scooter77@scooter77 raises some valid concerns, especially for those who have accounts with significant HIVE holdings.


If both the above proposals are rejected, then I will probably begin focusing my efforts on a solution that involves the elimination or partial elimination of the ability to cast a downvote within the Proof of Brain tribe (a solution that scooter77@scooter77 mentioned, but did not necessarily endorse). The net effect would be that you can still cast a downvote, but it will have zero effect on the POB reward pool.

Hive-Engine allows the tribe owner to disable all downvotes. That just requires the flip of a switch, so to speak (a simple adjustment to the token settings). However, the downvote remains an important tool for quickly responding to plagiarism. As such, we might want to invest in some development on the Hive-Engine side to enable POB downvotes for only a select group -- a 'community content moderators' group.



I apologize in advance for this "mass tagging" comment, but I know of no other way to get the word out to those who have not yet voted (on either proposal):
proofofbrainio@proofofbrainio
richardcrill@richardcrill
amr008@amr008
faireye@faireye
oldmans@oldmans
successfull@successfull
interpretation@interpretation
holovision@holovision
dwayne16@dwayne16
allcapsonezero@allcapsonezero
rxhector@rxhector
anadolu@anadolu
junkfeathers@junkfeathers
phusionphil@phusionphil
anacristinasilva@anacristinasilva
taskmaster4450@taskmaster4450
harpreetjanda@harpreetjanda
chorock@chorock
coffeefinance@coffeefinance
no-advice@no-advice
howweroll@howweroll
gillianpearce@gillianpearce
pandaparker@pandaparker
uwelang@uwelang
antonym@antonym
lordneroo@lordneroo
edicted@edicted
terminado@terminado
juanmiguelsalas@juanmiguelsalas
lunaticpandora@lunaticpandora
taskmaster4450le@taskmaster4450le
madstacks@madstacks
spinvest-leo@spinvest-leo
pouchon@pouchon
nickyhavey@nickyhavey
bozz@bozz
melbourneswest@melbourneswest
californiacrypto@californiacrypto
heruvim1978@heruvim1978
charcoalbuffet@charcoalbuffet
jfang003@jfang003
chireerocks@chireerocks
liotes.voter@liotes.voter
cryptoandcoffee@cryptoandcoffee
gank@gank
hivecoffee@hivecoffee
felipejoys@felipejoys
friendlymoose@friendlymoose
antisocialist@antisocialist
razackpulo.pob@razackpulo.pob
erikah@erikah
lebah.tribes@lebah.tribes
jongolson@jongolson
captaincryptic@captaincryptic
stickupboys@stickupboys
ashleykalila@ashleykalila
dera123@dera123
thatgermandude@thatgermandude
funnel@funnel
darkflame@darkflame
futurebrain@futurebrain
nonsowrites@nonsowrites
teapassion@teapassion
thoughts-in-time@thoughts-in-time
anaclark@anaclark
hatoto@hatoto
battleaxe@battleaxe
claudio83.pob@claudio83.pob
kryptodenno@kryptodenno
tfranzini@tfranzini
idiosyncratic1@idiosyncratic1
romirspc@romirspc
paulo.sar@paulo.sar
clixmoney@clixmoney
dealhunter@dealhunter
damla@damla
kamran-rkploy@kamran-rkploy
penderis@penderis
curatorcat.leo@curatorcat.leo
meesterboom@meesterboom
knowhow92@knowhow92
corporateay@corporateay
brianbeights@brianbeights
chronocrypto@chronocrypto
liaminit1@liaminit1
clicmaster@clicmaster
achim03@achim03
ph1102@ph1102
honeysaver.fund@honeysaver.fund
oldsoulnewb@oldsoulnewb
rumors@rumors
por500bolos@por500bolos
thranax@thranax
automaton@automaton
eonwarped@eonwarped
metzli@metzli
gubbatv@gubbatv
primersion@primersion
savagetobi@savagetobi
thelogicaldude@thelogicaldude
jlordc@jlordc
fredrikaa@fredrikaa
absolutfreedom@absolutfreedom
andy4475@andy4475
brofi@brofi
jersteemit@jersteemit
solairitas@solairitas
katerinaramm@katerinaramm
dylanhobalart@dylanhobalart
alexvan@alexvan
gadrian@gadrian
mimismartypants@mimismartypants
thatcryptodave@thatcryptodave
nobutsd1974@nobutsd1974
ruth-girl@ruth-girl
belemo@belemo
skylinebuds@skylinebuds
thegoliath@thegoliath
strenue@strenue
dwarflordnoj@dwarflordnoj
jmsansan.leo@jmsansan.leo
he-index@he-index
zanoz@zanoz
dalz@dalz
shawnlauzon@shawnlauzon
photophile@photophile
geekgirl@geekgirl
playbyhive@playbyhive
richardfyates@richardfyates
filotasriza3@filotasriza3
shortsegments@shortsegments
kriszrokk@kriszrokk
vlemon@vlemon
readthisplease@readthisplease
lookagain@lookagain
bluemoon@bluemoon
riandeuk@riandeuk
victor-alexander@victor-alexander
mimi05@mimi05
velourex@velourex
blockchainyouth@blockchainyouth
daniky@daniky
yintercept@yintercept
akumagai@akumagai