When a patient visits a doctor, a lawyer, or a spiritual leader, they carry with them numerous problems and matters deeply hidden in their hearts, seeking solutions; they view these professionals—whether doctor, spiritual leader, or lawyer—as a savior.
Why These Professions are allowed to have secrets of clients?
In society, all these professions are viewed with deep reverence and respect. When we see a doctor, we perceive them as a healer—a savior of sorts; when we see a spiritual leader or a priest, we regard them as being very close to God and treat them with great deference; similarly, we look to lawyers as the guardians of our rights.It is inherent in human nature that when a person views someone with deep reverence and respect, they willingly offer their heart to them; and when they regard someone as greater than themselves, they turn to that very person with their requests.That is precisely why, whenever clients visit these professionals, they end up revealing their secrets in their quest for solutions to their problems.
Secret to anyone is equivalent to Trust
A secret is like a trust; whether we share it with a professional or a friend, the recipient bears the responsibility of safeguarding it—just as we had kept it hidden in a corner of our heart—and ensuring it remains secure without revealing it to anyone else.
A confidant ought to honor the secret entrusted to them and never betray that trust; otherwise, the person who shared the secret loses faith, and their heart is left shattered.
Priority to save lives over secret
There are many situations where we are compelled to reveal our secrets to resolve our difficulties; however, if it is a matter of saving someone's life, then saving that life should certainly take precedence, and the secret ought to be disclosed.
Even in Islam, it is said that if you have to lie to save someone's life, you should tell it to a human being because a life is a very valuable asset.
Utalitarianism : Philosophical perspective
This brings to mind the utilitarian philosophy of Bentham and John Stuart Mill—"the greatest good for the greatest number"—which advocates minimizing harm and maximizing happiness. Therefore, if lives can be saved by revealing a secret, saving those lives is certainly the right course of action.
Example
Imagine for a moment that you are a psychologist, and a patient comes to you claiming to have planted a bomb in a public place—specifically, one that could cause an explosion in a park. It is certainly the doctor's moral responsibility to inform the police in order to save lives, as this is not merely a matter of confidentiality but a crisis involving potential loss of life.
What Would a World Without Privilege Look Like?
If the privilege protecting the confidentiality of information shared with professionals—such as doctors or lawyers—were to be abolished, clients would certainly lose trust in these professionals and refrain from disclosing sensitive information; this could lead to professional and ethical crises.
Maintaining confidentiality is, first and foremost, a matter of ethics; therefore, one should never compromise on one's ethics. One must keep ethical principles in mind and safeguard the secrets entrusted to them.
💫💫💫