Very interesting and intelligent post.
I think @krnel could benefit from your wisdom.
This quote here is immortal:
Morality doesn't exist without more than one conscious being.
My opinion was that morality is subjective truth only (and dependant on variables). He/she is adamant that it exists without subject as the perspective. That "good and bad" exists outside of conscious observation.
RE: What Role Does Consensus Have in Morality?