At this point, I’m not even pretending anymore, this is a full-blown Freida McFadden phase. You know when you keep going back to an author because they’ve trained your brain to expect chaos? Yeah, that. After a couple of her books, I’ve learned one thing, you don’t read her stories for comfort, you read them for the moment your jaw drops and your trust issues get upgraded.
Truly, this one tested my patience before it rewarded it.
Synopsis (No Spoilers, Stay Calm)
Blake is recently out of job but he needs money to pay off the mortgage on his brownstone. So, his fiance, Krista, suggests that they get a tenant. At least they could make good use of their rent money before Blake is able to get back on his feet and pay off the mortgage debt. When they finally get a tenant, a Whitney Cross, everything turns dark and the seemingly normal tenant-landlord dynamic begins to unravel into something far more sinister because the people living in the brownstone are not who they say they are.
Review & Personal Criticism
Let’s Address Blake, Because We Have To
For a significant chunk of this book, honestly, the first 150–200 pages, I struggled.
The character of Blake is boring as Jehovah’s Witness sermon about paradise. This isn't just boring in a slow burn way. It's too much explanation. Everything felt overly detailed, overly described, overly spelled out. I didn’t feel like I was discovering the story, I felt like it was being explained to me in a lecture.
At some point, I found myself drifting. Picking up the book, putting it down and telling myself, I’ll come back to it. I actually did pause reading this book for a while. Because if you’re going to drag me through pages of explanation, at least let me breathe.
But Here’s the Thing… It’s Freida McFadden so I couldn’t abandon it. Not because I was enjoying it at that point but because I know Freida McFadden. And if there’s one thing she’s going to do, it’s deliver a twist that makes you question your entire reading experience. So baby girl had to endure.
I pushed through the explanations, the slow pacing, the “Blake, please get to the point” moments. And then came the disrespectfully good twist. When it finally landed? It was Jaw on the floor situation. My sister almost helped me pick it up. lol
I’m not even exaggerating, I had to pause. I just sat there, stunned, processing what I had just read. It wasn’t just shocking, I mean the twist sent waves of realization through my brain as everything started rearranging itself. I started replaying scenes, reinterpreting conversations and questioning my own false assumptions. And suddenly, all that slow buildup clicked.
Do I forgive the slow start? Reluctantly, yes and that’s only because the payoff was worth it.
This book doesn’t just shock you, it unsettles you and leaves you slightly disoriented, like your brain just did a full 180 without warning. And honestly? That’s why we read thrillers.
This book is a lesson in patience. It might frustrate you at the beginning, kinda testing your attention span and you might even consider dropping it. But if you trust the process, if you can trust Freida, like I do, you’ll be rewarded with a twist that reminds you exactly why you picked up the book in the first place.
It’s not a smooth ride but it’s definitely a memorable one.
Rating in details
4.0/5
Beginning pacing: 6/10 (I struggled, I won’t lie)
Character engagement (early on): 5/10
Plot twist: 10/10 (no notes, just shock)
Overall satisfaction: 8.5/10
Would I recommend it? Yes, but with a warning: Don’t quit too early. The chaos is coming.
Do have a blessed week ahead💕
