This was a guilty pleasure of mine. I thought the show was horrible. Crappy storylines, bland dialogue, and very predictable.

It was the attitudes of the actors and their characters that changed things for me. I ended up loving the show and hung at every episode. My favorite part was the ending of season two as the Momma-Earp makes her monologue:

She took a break after season two to give birth. I didn't realize season 3 was out after reading your post! Thanks for the great article and the memories it brought.