Even hive official accounts don't downvote based on quality, they downvote only based on spam (or) copy. I think it is fair. But what you doing is not fair in my opinion. People have different skills and qualites. In a class, there are many children with different grades based on their skills, but no one should get 0 (or) no one should get 100 % downvote on their honest work and if they made their efforts. Downvote hurt others because there are people who depended on hive for their lives.