To be honest, it feels like it wouldn't affect anything even if we gave 50%. Like we have a flat HBD supply this year. (Excluding the HBD in DHF)

No, I am not saying we should give 50%. It would be a terrible idea.

15% is not a good deal, it is an okayish deal. We say on the tin that you get 15%, but when you try to exit HBD a good portion of it just gets lost to slippage.