I select those who I think are doing good stuff and deserve support.

Yeah, I take the same approach. But the position itself is not really responsible for anything, except block production.

We need some forum where people can put in their suggestions and step up to actually do stuff. It should be in the open where possible.

Its not going to be used. Hivers are very set in their ways. Those that are still around just kind of do their daily thing. I honestly think for anythign to change you would need to vote in a strategy like proposed above so I number of people lead the efforts.