RE: RE: How The Sun Really Shines - No Light Without A Tunnel!
You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: How The Sun Really Shines - No Light Without A Tunnel!

Words
463
Reading
3 min
Listen
Play
5y

Thanks again for this very clear blog on this topic. I have a small set comments, mostly with respect to one point.

First of all, I find the wording a bit confusing when you mentioned the following:

Initially, 2 protons fuse together and usually the pair breaks apart again immediately, but once in a while one of the protons is transmuted into a neutron. This happens due to the weak nuclear force in a process called beta decay.

Technically, a proton cannot ”decay” into a neutron as proton is lighter. For this to happen, the proton needs to have some non-vanishing kinetic energy. In fact, we have instead the reaction proton + proton to deuterium + positron + neutrino (which happens super rarely relative to proton + proton to proton + proton). We should rather call this a beta process in my opinion than a beta decay (as done in some of my recent works on neutrinoless double beta processes here and there).

I have the impression that this is what you meant, but I found it a bit confusing in the way it is currently written.

Moreover:

Hydrogen fusion is when 4 hydrogen nuclei (protons) come together to form one Helium nucleus.

and:

Two Deuterium nuclei can then merge to form a Helium nuclei, […]

This is incorrect: there is no such a reaction in which two deuterium nuclei directly fuse into a helium-4 nuclei in the Sun.

In fact, one possibility to form helium-4 requires 6 hydrogen nuclei in the Sun. It proceeds through the formation of two Helium-3 nuclei that then fuse into one helium-4 nucleus and two protons (as mentioned in fact in your blog). Here, there is no need for a beryllium intermediate state. The two helium-3 nuclei can indeed fuse directly.

If we want to go through a beryllium-7 state, this is also possible. However, we need to rely on the fusion of a helium-3 nucleus with a pre-existing helium-4 nucleus, that then produces a beryllium-7 nucleus which decays into a lithium-7 nucleus, that then fuses with an extra proton to give rise to beryllium-8 which finally decays into two helium-4 nuclei. Here we go, but with many more than 4 protons in total!

The two chains happen regularly in the Sun, although the second one is a higher energy version than the first one.

Finally, when you wrote:

In other words, its main source of energy is Hydrogen Fusion. [1]

In fact, as you can see hydrogen fusion clearly contributes to the whole process (when deuterium and proton fuse to helium-3), but it is not alone. We have many other fusion processes all over the place. In terms in energy, most of it comes in fact from these other processes.

Cheers and have a good week!