Oh I definitely like the dark one better then the light one. The colors from your dragenfruit are popping much more, the contrast in the image is much more pleasant for the eye, and that's because your eye is always drawn towards the brightest area in the photo. In case of the light image your dragonfruit is more falling back into the background. With the dark background the dragonfruit pops out and that's exactly what you want here.
RE: Same Light Setup. Light & Dark Photography