Yes, that adds it to blog, but not to the community.

And vice versa.

Yes I can add it to a community, but then I can't add it to my blog.

Have we removed the ability to add it to both?

I used to be able to choose "Add to my blog" in the advanced settings. I also recall the ability to be able to hit the ... icon by post title in my feed, to choose "Add to my blog".

Never had to cross post or pin to add a post to my community and my blog in the past. Is cross posting the preferred method now for adding a published post to a blog or community?