Us, Women, We Need to Stop Playing Musical Chairs...

Words
922
Reading
5 min
Listen
Play
8h

I have always found it curious how women can speak so eloquently about solidarity, empathy, and sisterhood while sometimes making a complete mess of the very relationships that should embody those principles. I am not talking about every woman, nor am I interested in turning an observation into a blanket condemnation of my own gender. What interests me is a particular social behavior that many women have either witnessed, experienced, or participated in at some point: the tendency to treat other women as competitors even when there is no reasonable justification for competition in the first place. The musical chairs analogy seems particularly appropriate here. In the game, everyone moves around while the music plays, but the moment it stops, somebody must lose. There is no room for everyone to sit down, and nobody wants to be the one left standing. Unfortunately, some women seem to approach friendships, professional environments, romantic relationships, and even ordinary social interactions with precisely this mentality. Someone else's opportunity becomes a threat, another woman's confidence becomes an offense, and an achievement that deserves recognition suddenly becomes a reason to question her character.

What makes this behavior particularly frustrating is the contradiction between its practice and its public denial. Women can be extraordinarily articulate when discussing the importance of emotional intelligence, mutual respect, and the difficulties imposed on us by a society that has historically encouraged competition over limited opportunities. Yet some of those same women will undermine another woman's credibility, invent unflattering nicknames, circulate personal information, disguise insults as jokes, or offer compliments that carry a carefully concealed sting. I have seen how easily criticism becomes a social currency, allowing people to establish their own position by diminishing somebody else's. The mechanisms are not always obvious, and that is precisely what makes them effective. Hostility can arrive disguised as concern, exclusion can be presented as an innocent misunderstanding, and cruelty can be dismissed as a harmless comment because nobody wants to acknowledge the intention behind it. The performance of friendliness remains intact while the actual relationship deteriorates. Everyone pretends the music is still playing, even when somebody has already kicked another woman's chair away.

There is also a particular discomfort in recognizing how often this competition revolves around things that should have nothing to do with a woman's worth: appearance, age, romantic attention, professional recognition, social status, or the simple ability to attract attention without asking permission. A woman succeeds, and someone immediately searches for an explanation that makes her success less legitimate. She must have been lucky, manipulative, privileged, or willing to do something questionable to get there. Her achievement becomes easier to tolerate once it has been reduced to a flaw in her character. Men engage in rivalry, gossip, and hostility too, of course, and male solidarity can be selective, exclusionary, or deeply harmful to others. Still, I have often found that men can be more willing to defend, encourage, or publicly acknowledge other men without treating every individual success as a personal defeat. That observation is not a scientific conclusion about the inherent nature of either sex. It is a criticism of a social pattern I find difficult to ignore. Solidarity means very little when it disappears the moment another person receives something we wanted for ourselves.

Perhaps the most revealing part of this problem is that genuine solidarity becomes most meaningful when it requires something from us. Supporting a sister, a cousin, a close friend, or a woman whose values and circumstances resemble our own is not necessarily difficult. Affection, shared history, and mutual loyalty already provide reasons to act kindly. The real test arrives when the woman in question is a stranger, a colleague competing for the same position, somebody whose appearance attracts attention, or someone whose success exposes our own insecurities. Can I acknowledge her achievement without searching for a reason to diminish it? Can I disagree with her without humiliating her? Can I recognize her humanity without needing her to become less successful, less attractive, less intelligent, or less visible than I am? These questions matter because solidarity is not simply a feeling we experience toward people we already like. It is also a decision about how we behave when our pride, interests, or prejudices encourage us to do otherwise. Without that distinction, sisterhood becomes little more than a convenient label for relationships that remain conditional.

I am not interested in romanticizing women or pretending that sharing a gender automatically creates a meaningful bond. It does not. Nor should we demand unquestioning loyalty from women who have every reason to criticize one another. Honest disagreement is not betrayal, and accountability is not a failure of empathy. What deserves scrutiny is the impulse to turn another woman's existence into a competition that she never agreed to enter. I would rather see women recognize one another's achievements without suspicion, establish boundaries without humiliation, and offer support without expecting obedience or repayment. None of this requires universal affection, artificial harmony, or the elimination of ambition. It requires something considerably more difficult: the willingness to stop treating another woman's gain as our own loss. The music will eventually stop for all of us, because opportunities, recognition, and circumstances change. The question is whether we will spend our lives pushing one another away from the chairs or finally understand that another woman's place at the table does not make ours any smaller.

All photographs and content used in this post are my own. Therefore, they have been used under my permission and are my property.