Yes, and I have explained why. I have a very similar discussion with noctury, please check below. He have been able to correct himself. I suggest you do the same.

@noctury

My view IS he view at Splinterlands community. What you do at X is upto you. However, at hive we are discouraging free cards. Definitely giveways on template writing is discouraged. Hope this helps.

So I agree with you. Please don't get downvoted.

Just because you were doing something for years doesn't make it right. Times have changed. The community has changed. The game has changed. Change with it...

PS: DO NOT SELF VOTE