I think you got on the list because you look too automated.
Getting to know people will help avoid this.

I asked for you to be taken off the list, because you had set rewards to burn, but I haven't gotten an answer back, which may be the only answer we get.
The fella has a criteria and once you've met it he has little choice, he has flagged too many others to make exceptions.
Give it some time for him to notice.