Let me start with those three points as general overview of my stance on the matter:
Also, I'm writing this comment on the fly as I'm reading your article, so some points might turn out to be already covered.
Witnesses should consider temporarily reducing HBD APR to ~6%
Absolutely ridiculous. It is exactly the opposite of what should be happening when price of Hive is low. It is already critically hard to justify keeping HBD in savings right now:
You can't reduce HBD APR to 6% because even within Hive ecosystem there are alternatives, unless of course the effect you want to achieve is to permanently discourage people from keeping large sums in HBD, or you also plan to destroy the alternatives giving people more reason to abandon the chain.
curb overspending and DHF outflows
My stake is far too low to ever take a deeper look in what is actually financed, but I know that most of development funds don't come from DHF, but should. Also the way DHF payouts are structured is incompatible with real world requirements, like f.e. it is a criminal liability to stop paying your employee when DHF stops paying you, so you need solid buffer which increases cost.
note that we are aware that this may cause conversions to happen
So you want to make sure they happen, ok...
The DHF is another major source of new, non-programmatic inflation.
Not entirely true. All funds in DHF come from regular inflation (well, except of ninjamine, but that's already lowered quite a bit). We are heavily underspending since forever due to return proposal, plus the funds are kept in HBD, which with low HIVE price made treasury stash quite big, so the allowed spending is also relatively big. It would be interesting to simulate what would happen if the funds were always kept as Hive and only converted to HBD on payout - how would that affect how much we can spend each hour (I suspect in the end it would just mean less funds returning through return proposal, but who knows).
Since there is no built-in cap on DHF outflows
There is, technically we are always spending everything that the cap allows, it is just that return proposal gives part of it back to treasury.
Add the Value Plan's annual 1M HBD
I think I'm missing something - what is a Value Plan and how it is financed if not through proposal?
Examples of Deliverables & KPIs We Want to See
I was under impression DHF was supposed to be used mainly for R&D, which in every organization represents a cost, hardly ever attributable to specific profits, it just allows organization to stay afloat on the market in the long run.
RE: How to Reduce Hive's Inflation Problem - Our New DHF Proposal Voting Criteria, HBD APR, and a Proposed Value Plan S.O.P