oh this looks sweet

A few months ago I commented that someone who dramatically edited their proposal mid vote shouldn't be allowed to do so and got a single downvote from that OP who is a whale and that's led to my account

nice i'm in

now it's no longer hidden due to low reputation but "muted in splinterlands" all this for commenting that I didn't think a proposal should be edited once voting has taken place

i'm tentatively for this but worry that the people proposing and voting on what is essentially monetary policy don't understand any of this well enough to be able to accurately predict outcomes

all that literally because of 1 single downvote from the original author that is censorship

yet

Great proposal, love it

Sounds like a whale club which could be useful but alas whales controlling everything is bad for mass market growth worst part about it is if you want to join later then you need to be approved, suddenly

love how edits are still shown with strikethroughs, great step forward for transparency

most people aren't involved in proposals and even fewer in pre-proposals someone who's dumped hundreds or even thousands into this game is not going to participate in an event that gives them .001% voting

yeah looks fine, i'd perhaps bump up the 5% a little but otherwise think it's a fine proposal

sounds like a great plan

Yeah and also seeing how if a single whale disagrees with your comment then it can get hidden just like that with a single downvote real great system we got here for fostering discussion

Even though I'm on board with the edits as well as the original proposal. I think this sets a terrible precedent and you shouldn't be allowed to edit a proposal once it's been submitted and voted upon.

Really fucked up that you can edit a proposal after it's already been submitted and voted on. I say this as someone who agrees with both the original and the updated version. I just think this creates

This is an ideal solution to deal with the bot issue

yeah this "community voting" system just ensures whales call all shots going forward this game is doomed if they don't fix that

100%

this is literally how every proposal starts and ends