Highlights on the N Squared Voting Law from The Steem Whitepaper

Some issues have been discussed by high profile members of the community recently, here a are a couple of posts

Is Everybody Heading For the Doors - @gavett

Increasing Curation, Demand for Steem Power, and Community Interaction - @ned

I think there is a fundamental underlying reason for these issues - the N Squared voting power law. I made a post about this recently.
Your Votes Don't Matter ~ Back of the Envelope Steem Power Madness Calculations

To give some more background on the issue, here is a screenshot from the Steem Whitepaper [PDF], with my annotations.

I think this shows that there are reasons to use a nonlinear function for voting, but there is no truly compelling reason to use a n^2 law. We have real world data now that shows that n^2 is too extreme (posts with 100 votes often do not earn as much as posts with e.g. one whale vote for example).

Even projects like project Curie could not be successful until they onboarded large whales such as @berniesanders. This would not be necessary if dolphins had real voting power.

Let's see how a N to the 1.1 power law would compare to the N squared law.

An account with 100k SP would still be more powerful than an account with 1k SP. However, the effect is much less pronounced since the 100k SP account is only "158 times more powerful" versus the 1k account. This is contrasted with the n^2 law, where the 100k account is "ten thousand times more powerful".

More analysis is needed, but I wanted to get this out there since we are discussing this in the Beyond Bitcoin channel today.

Email "decentralize it" to bryangmyrekcom@gmail.com to join my new newsletter about decentralized technologies, nature, and more.

Bryan Gmyrek lives in sunny Arizona with his wife, three sons, and two golden puppies. He earned a Ph.D. in physics for his work at Fermilab and also enjoys computers, nature photography and blockchains.

Follow @nonlinearone for more great pics and posts.

H2
H3
H4
3 columns
2 columns
1 column
Join the conversation now
Logo
Center