Every time?
I am quite a logical person too, but sometimes it is the most logical choice to hear for your guts.
How do you feel, Mr. Spock?
Also consider Decision Fatigue. The more you decide, the more exhausted you get and the worse your future decisions get (until you have a good sleep).
Do you really THINK every time before changing gear or switch on the turn signal when you drive?
RE: The Science Of Intuition: Why You Can Trust Your Gut Feelings More Than You Think