Hi! As a new member, and still getting used to the guild management, which i think is really interesting (still understanding some of the rules), and by far deeper than any other guild ive been, yet i think there is plenty of room for improvement. Specifically on the score table. By multiplying the scrolls and dec contributions you get your score, so its easy to follow, but this has a problem, and is that Dec is weightened equal to scrolls. Yes, as a new member its easy to complain about that, because im almost at no scrolls, so i have nothing to get more of them (specially if the bar is full atm), so i can just "manipulate" the dec part of the equation. The problem of this is that minimizes dec contributions, specially for older guild members, because with higher scrolls, even with a minimum dec donation, overpowers any newer member, making them almost "unkickable". And i ask, what is the benefit of a scroll from last season, or going beyond, what is the benefit of a scroll from 3, 6 months or 2 years before now? Nothing. After a new season scrolls reset to 0, so just the scrolls from the current season are worth. With dec this doesnt happen, because every dec contributed even from the first day the guild was born, is still benefiting everyone, by having upgraded buildings all this time.
My proposal? Scrolls should only be counted only after the last reset, so for the current season, because before that, noone benefits from them.
So what's the problem? Minimal dec contributions. Scrolls benefit everyone (only in this season), but it cost nothing to get them, is just a consequence of playing, so just by playing (even doing nothing by botting your account) you are contributing scrolls, and this is not true for dec, as dec cost money, and you have to spend to get them. By seeing members list, more than half of the members, in many months, have contributed poor amount of decs. 50, 100, or less than 1000 dec in months, or even in all of 2022? Thats far from being a contribution, considering all the value you get from being in the guild.
So, benefits for change this? Boost dec contributions, because now there are many people with very low contributions, and to level up in the score table, you must just donate a couple decs, and this way new people will not be at a huge disadvantage just because other people joined long ago, but has not even donated much dec.
Sorry if something is not well written or is hard to understand, but im not english native. Sorry if the proposal seems kind of rude, but is just a proposal for the benefit of everyone.