Holding Moon

I recently watched tutorials on editing a photo through the use of masking several layers in a photo.
I have tried two holding moon pictures.

The first

The second

There are some errors in above pictures, but as a beginner i think i did well.

Tools used :-
PicsArt
Snapseed
Adobe Lightroom

---

The hand in the photos above is mine. Please share your thoughts on above photos and say which one is better.