I think this proposal will help the guild I play in, but... Does this proposal incentivize guilds to advance even if they don't have the players and those players don't have the cards to defend next tier frays? To me, I may be wrong, this proposal does that. Guild brawls should be for competing not just for farming sps, merits and crowns. You can't compete, you do not advance. I am right now defending an easy fray in tier 3 (gold level regular foil chaos + untamed) against only 4 more players. That means half of the guilds are not defending the fray. You give more candy to guilds if they advance, more unprepared guilds will advance, less fun... I may be missing something